What makes you laugh?

Not many modern television comedians make me laugh.  Some irritate me.  Some bore me stiff.  Some I positively hate.

I like the old masters of mirth: Laurel and Hardy, some of Charlie Chaplin’s films, Les Dawson and Ken Dodd, Tony Hancock, Sid James, Tommy Cooper, Eric Sykes, The Marx Brothers. Who else?  Who else who’s a reasonably new modern comedian?  Well there’s Charlie Brooker, Jack Dee, Peter Kay, Al Murray, Harry HillillHi.  And er … Well maybe there are comedians I’ve never seen who I would love, but in the 21st century, as far as I can see, there’s a pretty low comedy count. Either that or I’m losing my sense of humour.

I think what I enjoy most about Laurel and Hardy is the sheer anarchic destruction in many of their films.  I remember a piano that had to be winched up to the top of a tall block of flats.  It was dropped and smashed so many times that right at the top, at the destination apartment, the disappointed concert pianist was given a couple of keys and part of the broken lid.  Another time an entire house was destroyed by accident, the result of bungling DIY decoration attempts.

A lot of the joy in the TV series Men Behaving Badly depended on idiocy, namely the idiocy of the likeable male key characters, whose female counterparts were bright and long suffering.  I’ll never forget one conversation when the girlfriend of one of them was talking to her boyfriend’s best mate, and curiosity prompted her to ask what they talked about in their many long beer-fuelled discussions.  “Well,” said the cheery Tony, “all kinds of things. For instance the other night we discussed how they should close the Channel Tunnel at weekends so it could be used as a giant bowling alley.”  He looked hopefully at her.  “You should join our discussions, they’re really fun.” She politely declined.

Absurdity is nice in all its forms.  I didn’t like the early Blackadders, but I loved the First World War ones, where Hugh Laurie plays the genial upper class moron, and Stephen Fry the bumptious Colonel.  I remember years ago when Stephen Fry and Ben Elton were on a late night BBC2 programme, doing comedy improvisations, which was really good, I remember a ‘pretend pub’.  And The Thin Blue Line with Rowan Atkinson as the pompous policeman.  Very very funny.  Intelligent, inventive humour.  And, it seems, the best comics are often incredibly intelligent: Stephen Fry and Hugh Laurie are acknowledged as geniuses, while Les Dawson was no academic slouch: he wrote long incredibly complicated novels. And I believe that Al Murray, the apparently moronic xenophobic ‘pub landlord’, has a glittering academic record (I think his discipline was history).

The modern view of Benny Hill is that he was sexist.  I don’t agree, I think his comedy was inspired and brilliant. Okay it had an element of saucy seaside postcards, but what’s wrong with that?  Each sketch was a full length story, silent for the most part, the comedy visual, and the sexist stuff that he’s condemned for was only a very small part, usually right at the end, a sort of innocent nudge nudge wink wink, never the downright crudity so common today.  The Plank was also a silent comedy and a gem of invention, with Eric Sykes, Tommy Cooper, Arthur Lowe and others following the fortunes of a long plank of wood being transported on a van’s roof, and coming off on the way, with predictably bizarre results.

To my mind the beginning of the death of plenty of good comedy started with the advent of ‘alternative comedy’. It heralded the arrival of hours of unfunny drudgery, when talentless nonentities who were ‘young’ mouthed obscenities, jumped around awkwardly and tried to be original, succeeding in being about as entertaining as a limp lettuce.  I remember one episode of Hale and Pace on television, when the main jokes were people having their faces repeatedly pressed into cow dung, throwing geriatric people in wheelchairs into a dustcart, jibes about how they hated the Isle of Wight, and pretending to put a kitten in a microwave oven.  Of course the joke was convoluted, obviously they didn’t fry the kitten, but to even raise the prospect of it, to me, can never ever be considered funny.  There was cold heartless viciousness about their humour that cut like a knife.  Has alternative comedy finally found the forgotten windswept grave it deserves?  I very much hope so.

The essence of laughing at, or with somebody, seems to me to be that you want to be ‘let in’ to their life, for which reason you have to like them on some level, or at least like something about them.  It’s surely impossible not to like a genial character such as David Walliams, and that’s one reason why you’ll make that extra effort to enjoy his humour, because you like him, you want to be inside his little comedy world.  I find that the cold hard inscrutable face of Jimmy Carr smacks of a mystified undertaker and to me there’s something satanic about the sex-obsessed Keith Lemon; neither of those two men can ever cut the comedy magic for me.  And Jim Davidson can certainly be funny, but his sinister side anaesthetises some of the laughs, as if his comedy engine gets an occasional starvation of petrol.

I remember some Monty Python sketches that were fairly funny, but not that many of them.  The cartoons that were supposed to be so inspirational were downright boring.  And I thought The Life of Brian was irritating, tedious, blasphemous and completely lacking in any kind of merit.  Maybe I missed the point of it, but if I did then I’m glad.

In most kinds of comedy there’s a strange, almost mystical, balancing point that the masters of comedy know by instinct.  One side of a fence it is funny, the other side is insanity.  Some people straddle the line and occasionally come down on the wrong side.  The Young Ones I found infinitely revolting with the one with the staring eyes talking about vomit, and others looking just plain deranged.  John Cleese in Fawlty Towers was generally extremely funny.  And yet.  Some of the scenes where he yells at and beats Manuel (The Spanish waiter) verge right on the edge of that fence of good taste, and almost fall across it.

Sometimes, when people bend their gender for laughs, again, it can seem as if that elusive line has been well and truly crossed.  Matt Lucas is a fine comedian, but his  women always struck me as too convincingly real to be funny. And I think Peter Kay is one of the funniest and most likeable men I’ve ever seen, but his large, monstrous Northern Ireland woman character he used to do appeared almost macabre in her androgynousness.  Mrs Brown’s Boys, the new BBC comedy, is hilarious in the main part.  But when the lead woman, played brilliantly by a man, settles down to talk about with her (his) woman co-star, and seems to enjoy wallowing in explicit details about female sexuality, something jars and clicks on the distaste button for me.

Women comediennes?  I think Ronnie Ancona is captivatingly brilliant in her portrayals and imitations, and very very funny.  Catherine Tate is also lovely, and a gifted comic in many of her comic parts.  But her ‘nasty old lady’ character?  Or when she plays a bald gay man?  Maybe I’ve just not capable of appreciating her talents but those two, frankly terrify me.  And Jo Brand yes, she is really funny.

Talking of Brands, how about Russell Brand?  I never even knew he even purported to be a comedian until recently and I’m surprised anyone can envisage him as such.

Here’s some black humour for you.  When I was a small boy I helped a dear old carpenter do some work, and he chatted away about his grandfather, who used to let him work with him, and told me about the coffins the grandfather would make, and how if someone died of dropsy they had to nail the lid down quick or else the body would swell up and they’d be unable to get the lid on at all.

And here’s something downright sinister. A well known comedian (I won’t give his name) was doing his stand-up act on television.  He referred to the recent rape and murder of a woman that had been currently in the news, and he said with a smirk, how the reference had turned him on sexually.  There was a momentary lapse of laughter from the audience, a shocked pause, but he hardly noticed and carried on.  I couldn’t believe what I’d heard. Ever afterwards whenever I’ve seen this ‘comedian’ I remembered that and I felt chilled and horrified, and the sight of him repelled me, as if he was the personification of evil.

Another odd thing about laughter.  It can cover nerves.  At the time of the 2011 London riots, the trouble came quite close to where I live and I was talking to someone about the prospect of the riot coming our way.  He said yes, he’d spoken to someone in town and the violence might be coming in our direction.  And he laughed.  He was scared and he laughed.  It had to be a nervous reaction.  And the same afternoon exactly the same  thing happened with someone else, he laughed too.  I never understood it.

I think Charlie Brooker is a great young comedian.  He’s cynical and self deprecating and has a gloomy outlook on life, and he sees through the puff and bluster of everyday things and debunks them.  Good for him, he’s a genuinely funny man.  Jack Dee, too.  He never smiles, he looks downright miserable, but there’s something about him you can like, he can connect.

The best humour is observation, and seeing the world at a funny angle.  I was chatting to a neighbour who had just witnessed my cat torturing a mouse, before I’d managed to stop him, and now , mercifully the mouse was dead.  I said how awful it was to witness the mouse’s torture.  “Ah well,” said my acquaintance.  “You don’t know.  That mouse might have been a child molester and deserved it.”  The same man, when I was discussing my theory that in years to come each person might have a clone of him/herself growing in a laboratory, so that when the time comes there’ll be a full set of lungs, heart, liver etc ready to transplant with no rejection issues, he said yes, certainly good idea.  “Why else do you think I had kids?  When my boy gets to be 16 I’m having his kidneys!”

I loved the excellent American comedy series, Cheers.  The characters were the comedy: remember the handsome-but-shallow Ted Danson, who never quite won the heart of the beautiful and brilliant Diana, or the classic bore postman, and barman Woody who had nothing between his ears except good natured innocence, not forgetting rude waitress Carla who snarled at all the customers?   Frazier, the boffin who was clearly intellectually their superior, lacked common sense and cut a fond figure of pompous absurdity with his deadpan funereal-faced wife Lilith.

Absurdity, pomposity, meanness, vanity.  Comedy lies in the puncturing of someone’s delusion about themselves, or perhaps, at its heart in itself it’s a kind of strange delicious teasing cruelty.  The humour lies, I think, in balancing and adjusting that cruelty so that you hardly notice it’s there.  It’s a delicate art and it’s a difficult balance.  Deliberately ‘funny’ writing can sometimes fall flat, yet when someone delivers something straight and an odd edge of absurdity creeps in there can be nothing funnier.

So what is humour?  A joy in shared cruelty?  A wallowing in pricking pomposity?  A kind of psychic mental hug?  A release from misery in escapism? An exercise in absurdity?  Maybe it’s a combination of all these.  Or maybe it’s something so elusive and delicate that when you try to define it, it disappears.

The biggest aspect of comedy is that it is as personal as musical taste and it’s certain that what I love you will probably hate and vice versa.

So what makes you laugh?  I’d really like to know.


9 thoughts on “What makes you laugh?

  1. Very good indeed, I Like: most Python, Fawlty Towers, Charlie Brooker, Dom Joly, Ed Byrne, Bill Hicks, Steven Wright, the films of Kevin Smith, Trailer Park Boys, The Flight of the Conchords, most of Jo Brand and Catherine Tait, Peter Cook, some of Frankie Boyle, and a few other bits and bobs I can’t think of right now. I hate: The Thin Blue Line, Mr Bean, Michael McIntyre, some fat twat with blonde hair I’ve seen on excerpts who I think you mentioned above, Benny Hill, Roy Chubby Brown, and any women stand up comedians who try to get laughs by talking about vaginas. 🙂


    1. Hello Terry, thanks. Yes I also like most of yours, but not heard of some of them. Frankie Boyle, I remember one of his jokes that was really scatalogical, but on the whole, yes I like him. And absolutely agree about the women coms . When they talk about that kind of thing, yuk!


  2. What a great blog post! Another one! A well-thought-out and in-depth look at comedy and what emotions it might, or might not trigger. I would have to agree with many of your thoughts, Geoff. Your clever paragraphs got me thinking and realizing that I really don’t find ‘on-purpose’ comedy that funny. An element of ‘forced humour’ is ever-present and as such the tickle-me-silly moments are completely lacking. Suffice to say I laugh loudest and longest over ridiculous, everyday happenings that come out of the blue—like the comment a small child utters in total innocence, or the dreaming dog who wakes suddenly and runs into a wall! Those moments really make me laugh I had a wonderful ‘giggle’ recently with someone I have only known for a short time. We were at a barbecue party and our hostess said that she had a gluten-free bap for him. Producing the bap she apologized that its top had exploded as it defrosted, whereupon I exclaimed; “it’s excited to see you, Jack!” For some unexplained reason that tickled us both and we giggled for the rest of the evening; the stupidity of exploding, emotional baps being altogether very silly! Needless to say I do find funny animal videos hilarious—and as for my dreams; they make me laugh for days! I have a vivid imagination and my mind conjures up the most ridiculous scenarios. The best dreams usually involve a nomadic beast of some description—but that’s another story for another time! Thank you for your wonderful post, Geoff. With silly chortles and best wishes for the coming week, Marina 


    1. Thanks for those Marina, I can just imagine that bap exploding. And the funny animals, yes, marvellous. I never heard of funny dreams, they sound like real fun. Likewise have a good week, and thanks for your nice words.


  3. I really enjoyed your post Geoff. In fact, it made me smile more than most of the comedians you mentioned. For me the funniest things are things that are incidentally funny rather then contrived. Although I’ve wracked my brains to come up with who makes me laugh and here goes though be warned it’s a short list. I agree with you on Peter Kay and I have to confess to being rendered borderline hysterical at The Idiot Abroad. I really like Would i Lie to You which I think is probably one of the funniest things on telly at the moment. Apart from that, I’m basically humourless.


    1. Hello EL. You couldn;t be humourless to write as you do – I suspect your humour is very dry. Once saw the Idiot Abroad, never seen Would I lie to you. Loving Dare to Lose, what a swine that headmaster was, v much like Nicola and her friends.


      1. Actually I have a confession to make, I went to the cinema today to see This Is The End (the one where lots of actors play themselves during the apocalypse). It’s completely puerile and I laughed like a drain. It’s made me fear that I could have the sense of humour of a 14 year old boy.

        I’m so thrilled that you are liking Dare To Lose. I’m always terrified when someone tells me they are reading anything I’ve written. I am loving Rock’n’Roll Suicide. Have you read any Bateman? Jack Lockwood reminds me a little bit of the protagonist in the Mystery Man series. I can’t put my finger on why but he just does.


  4. Oooh Geoff, what a cracking post! And very thought provoking it is too. Here’s something – my favourite comedian is… Russell Brand! I know you don’t ‘get’ him. He’s been on my bucket list for ages and I finally get to see him perform in an intimate venue in my hometown later this year. I first found him when he presented Big Brother’s Big Mouth about 10 years ago and he was utter filth but somehow he wasn’t at all offensive with it. In fact I found him endearing. I consider that an art form in itself. As his popularity grew I read more and more about him and even went as far as reading both of his autobiographies. He is a very talented writer, he has an extensive vocabulary which simply falls from his lips, words I’ve never heard before – he’s so articulate. I love his personal story too. His days as a drug and sex addict are heavily documented but hearing him talk about it in his own words and then go in to recovery and come out the other side, and now being an advocate for drug addiction recovery, even addressing parliament – well, I find him a remarkable man and can’t wait to see him in action on stage later this year.

    Moving on, I used to howl at Brian Conley in his ‘hey day’ but I might have been ever so slightly biased as my brother was his musical director for a long time and through him we got to know a lot about Brian the person, not the star. A lovely bloke.

    But I always hanker after my past and I truly believe the oldies are goodies. Many hilarious hours were spent as a child watching Fawlty Towers, Butterflies, Man About The House, The Good Life… shall I go on? Oh how I love them all ’til this day! I also have fond memories of Dick Emery, Harry Worth and Benny Hill, and not to forget my favourites, Morecambe & Wise and Bruce Forsyth.

    The funniest TV comedy I’ve ever seen is Friends. It never fails to make me laugh out loud even if I’ve seen the episodes 4 or 5 times. Only Fool and Horses is a close runner-up.

    I could talk forever on this subject so I’d better stop for fear of boring you to tears! 🙂 hehe.

    Nice one Geoff! X


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s